Dear Rt. Hon. Ralph T. O'Neal, Premier of the British Virgin Islands,
I am very concerned about threats to Beef Island’s marine areas in the British Virgin Islands.
Beef Island boasts mangroves that are integrated with sea grass, important dry tropical forest, salt ponds and coral reef habitats. The ecosystem of Hans Creek Lagoon, a marine protected area, is crucial for sustaining viable fisheries and throughout the British Virgin Islands. The proposed hotel, mega-yacht marina and golf course complex would destroy this world-class treasure.
Beef Island has the most important mangrove ecosystem in the BVI, second in acreage only to far-flung Anegada. All of Tortola's nine mangrove ecosystems have already been decimated or destroyed by development. Mangrove systems provide nurseries for hatchling birds and juvenile fish, homes for lobster and conch, and feeding grounds for waders and waterfowl.
Destruction of the Beef Island natural systems will be a devastating blow to both the fishing and the tourist industries. The entire ecosystem is important ecologically and economically to both these cornerstones of the BVI’s success.
Researchers have found up to 80% of all commercially important fish species live in Hans Creek. No other area has such a high recorded diversity. It is a hugely important nursery habitat which supplies other parts of the BVI with big fish.
BVI legislation recognizes the importance of the environment. The problem is holding the government accountable and enforcing these laws. International confidence in the BVI's decision-making process has been shaken by several contraventions of the Planning Act. These form the basis of the Virgin Islands Environmental Council's challenge.
For example, the Planning Act says that a development has to obey all written laws in the territory, and the Fisheries Regulations says that: "No person shall carry out any development activity, which may or is likely to adversely impact on a marine protected area." Yet the proposed development will devastate both Hans Creek Marine Protected Area and Beef Island’s largest salt pond to the east.
Additionally, I am gravely concerned about the Development Agreements that pre-agreed planning permission, and the Order that was passed to allow the Minister alone to approve all developments exceeding USD10m in value.
I urge you to review these decisions promptly. An agreement to revisit the process at this stage, as called for by VIEC, would ensure that worldwide confidence is restored in the BVI decision-making process.
